When people ask me what I do, my first answer would be: “I’m a veterinarian”.
After hearing this answer, they might begin to try and squeeze a free consultation out of me by saying “I have a dog with a problem…” I would then explain that I’m not that kind of veterinarian, as many of the things I learned at vet school have since been unlearned in the name of conservation.
The principles of animal production taught us that low-performing animals deserve the cleaver and high producers (i.e. those animals that produce a lot of offspring) should be kept. It is the other way around in conservation breeding: highly represented genes become least priority. The object is to have as much genetic diversity as possible and this can only be achieved by having all the animals in your collection ‘represented’ by their offspring.
What then, is the purpose of captive breeding? It is considered by many as one of the most expensive and labour-intensive methods available for conservation. For this, it is not very popular among field biologists. It takes away wildlife from their natural habitat, enabling them to develop behaviours that are ‘unnatural’. For some, it is synonymous to domestication, perhaps even for the pet trade. For others, it is an important supplement to habitat restoration and protection. In the eyes of many, there is a fine line between breeding for (commercial) production, and breeding for conservation, and this line has been manipulated to serve the purpose of one or the other. Funny, it sounds almost immoral.
The Philippine spotted deer Cervus alfredi conservation programme was initiated during the late 80’s after field biologists found out that the animal has been extirpated over much of its range. This animal, unique to the West Visayas (or Negros-Panay) Faunal Region, can now only be found in two of the five islands in which it formerly occurred. The same is true for the Visayan Warty Pig Sus cebifrons, which shares the same habitat and range as the Philippine spotted deer. For this, another conservation programme was initiated for the ill-fated pig. These programmes comprised of a series of approaches, including, but not limited to, the proposal of new protected areas that cover most of the animal’s existing strongholds; habitat restoration; education and awareness; training of relevant personnel; institutional capacity building; and conservation breeding. Three Biodiversity Conservation Centers were put up not only to hold the conservation breeding programmes, but also to serve as operation, training and education hubs for conservationists working in the area. These centres also serve as reservoirs of genetic material. For instance, one of the major threats of the Visayan warty pig, and indeed, many of its relatives in the Philippines, is genetic contamination. This threat may be considered grave because of its cryptic and nearly irreversible nature. Domestic pigs owned by people living at the forest edges have mated with their wild counterparts, effectively “contaminating” their DNA. Evidences of this threat have been recorded and some of these hybrids have been caught in the wild and misidentified as pure breeds. Up to this day, nobody knows how many hybrids there are in the wild. They continue to thrive and mate and spread their genes among our critically endangered pigs.
This initiative and others similar to it lead to Memoranda of Agreement between the Philippine’s Department of Environment and Natural Resources and concerned international and local institutional partners. These paved the way for the captive breeding of the Philippine spotted deer and the Negros bleeding-heart pigeon at the Silliman University – Center for Tropical Conservation Studies (SU-CenTrop) in Dumaguete City; the Visayan warty pig, Panay bushy-tailed cloudrat, Visayan writhed-billed hornbill and the Blue-headed raquet-tailed parrot at the Mari-it Conservation Park at the West Visayas State University College of Agriculture and Forestry in Iloilo; and the Visayan tarictic hornbill and the Philippine eagle-owl at the Negros Forests and Ecological Foundation Biodiversity Conservation Center (NFEFI-BCC) in Bacolod City. All of these events are world’s firsts and have contributed not only to the increase in individual species numbers, but also served to renew commitments of partner institutions to Philippine conservation.
The animals played their role well as educators and ambassadors: educators for local and international biologists and conservationists who will otherwise have no idea about each of the species breeding behaviours (knowledge of which, is invaluable for on-site conservation of each of the species); and ambassadors for Filipinos who have not encountered them in books, television and other forms of education available to us. Nothing beats encountering the animal in the flesh, unless of course one encounters them in the wild.
![Ronnie’s Hearts [Lou Jean Cerial - April 2007]](http://emlastica.files.wordpress.com/2007/05/dsc04736b.jpg)


I’ve had the opportunity to see the Philippine spotted deer at CenTrop and, if I remember it right, the Visayan tarictic hornbill and the Visayan warty pig at NFEFI-BCC. For what it’s worth, if not for these breeding programmes I would probably not have been able to see what they look like in the flesh.
I’m definitely for the conventional in-situ conservation. But I also understand the necessity of breeding programmes especially if the habitats of threatened species continually decline and eventually fail to support important wildlife species, moreso despite the numerous habitat restoration efforts implemented there.
For example, we know that the Negros-Panay Faunal Region has probably seen the most massive forest loss, if not the most rapid rate of deforestation, in the country. Negros Island can attest to that. I’m not sure if forest habitat restoration efforts have been successful in that faunal region; and I hope that they have, of course. But what if they have not? What if, despite the forest restoration programmes, the conditions and area of the forests have still not improved? Or maybe just barely? The continuous decline in forests habitats will, therefore, mean that it can no longer, or may not, support viable populations of wildlife. Hence, the wildlife species will soon decline as a result of lack of good habitats.
Simplistic as that logic seems, it is why I believe captive breeding has its merits and has its role to play in the conservation of our threatened species. I guess I’m just willing to explore all viable alternatives to ensure that our important species continue to remain.
hi: would you know kung anong progress/status ng captive-breeding of the bleeding-hearts at the Silliman University – Center for Tropical Conservation Studies?
Hello, the Negros bleeding-heart pigeons bred for the first time in captivity this year a the SU-CenTrop. Both chicks fledged last April. I will post a new blog on this, but right now, I have to work on the paper, which will be presented at the conference of the Veterinary Practitioners Association of the PHilippines. The paper will be a follow-up of Cariño et al, (2007) presented during the last WCSP meeting in Davao.
The Bleeding hearts conservation programme is made possible under the aegis of a MOA between Bristol Zoo and the DENR. Technical support came from FFI, Bristol Zoo and other international partners whilst financial support came from (of course) international partners as well.
[...] her previous post, Em discussed the country’s efforts at breeding its most threatened species. High-profile [...]
Dear emlastica,
I am a wildlife enthusiast from the other side of the globe and regular correspondent on several zoo related websites. I am very interested in the wildlife of the Phillipines and hope to travel there in the next year or so.
I would love to learn more about the unique wildlife here and know much has been lost due to large scale forestation. I would also like to visit some of the captive-breeding centres if that is possible?
Anyhow, what prompted me to write is the cloud rats captive breeding. You have 2 species Crateromys and Phloeomys. Which of the 6 species are bred in captivity at the special university centers?
Regarding wildlife: are any mainstream zoos involved in modern captive-breeding management of endangered species in the Phillipines too? I only know that the Avilon Zoo outside Manilla is a good place for breeding of native wildlife.
Thanks,
Jelle
kifaru04@hotmail.com
Hello Jelle,
Yes, it is possible to visit conservation breeding centres in the country. I work with three of them, fortunately, so you can contact me if you plan to come over next year. There are only a few structured programmes for Philippine wildlife in proportion to the many threatened species in the countries. This is because of the high cost involved in pursuing this method for conserving species.
We do have two genera of cloud rats, and a breeding programme is in place for Crateromys heaneyi, or the Panay bushy-tailed cloud rat at the Mari-it Conservation Park in Panay. It is being run in close collaboration with the West Visayas State University and the Department of Environment and Natural Resources.
As far as I know, although Avilon Zoo does breed some wildlife, they are not involved in any structured conservation breeding programmes, apart from loaning the majority of Philippine Eagle Owls for the Philippine Owls Conservation Programme. The conservation centres doing captive breeding in the Philippines tend to be specialised and are not ‘main stream’ unlike Avilon Zoo and others. Examples are the Negros Forests and Ecological Foundation, Inc. Biodiversity Conservation Center, Mari-it Conservation Park and the Philippine Eagle Center in Davao.
I must admit that the Philippines as a country has not reached the apex of the zoo evolution yet (Zoo Conservation Strategy)
Thank you for your comment and I hope to hear from you if you do want to come and visit.
Best wishes,
Em
Dear Em,
I am indeed planning to come over sometime in the third week of January 2009. I would sincerely appreciate to get in touch with you by e-mail if at all possible as I would both love to visit the 3 centres in Dumaguete, Bacolod and Iliolo and see for myself the progress made since your last reply.
I am arriving in Cebu and intend to visit Negros, Panay (ofcourse), the Mindoro tamaraw center (well I still need to get in touch with the responsible folk – contacts/guidance appreciated) and Leyte-Samar-Bohol.
You can contact me at the e-mail below. I explain in my reply e-mail more about myself and what I do as a zoo volunteer in NL.
Please, please do so at your earliest convenience, as it is getting close in time!
Keep up the good work.
Regards,
Jelle
Hi Em,
I hope all is well with you in your new role.
Just to let you know that I am linking to this page from http://hubpages.com/hub/Dumaguete-zoo
Best Wishes,
Take Care
Peter